Tuesday, March 31, 2009

So You Think You Can Dance Australia, and why my fellow Australians shit me to tears

(Apologies if this post seems a little scattered, the brain fog from my medication change is really kicking my ass today. I hate struggling to express myself, I really do.)

I admit it, I have a deep and driving love for So You Think You Can Dance. It's my guilty teevee pleasure, and I rarely miss an episode. I have to say, though, that the predictable-yet-uncool results of the last two shows have got me pretty pissed off.

For those not familiar with the show (or those who watch any version than the Aussie one, as I'm unsure if they follow the same format or not) the show is essentially Idol for dancers. A "top twenty" is selected by the judges, consisting of ten men and ten women. They are paired up, and then dance new choreography every week for the votes of the Australian public.

From the "top twenty" to the "top ten", the votes of the viewers determine which six dancers (three male, three female) will go before the judges, who then decide which male dancer and which female dancer out of that bottom six will be leaving that week. From the "top ten" until the finale, the decision as to who will leave is determined entirely by the votes of the viewers.

Last week was the first week that the votes of the show's viewers were the sole deciding factor in who would be leaving, with the judges no longer playing a part in the decision. Before that results show, the top ten looked like this:



The votes came in. The two dancers who received the lowest number of votes and would hence be leaving the show that night were these two:



and



Notice anything?

The following week, which was of course the second week where the verdict on who stayed and who left depended entirely on audience votes, had a bit of a twist. One of the remaining female dancers was injured, and had to leave the show. Gianne (picture above) who was the last woman to be voted off, returned in her place for one more week.

When the votes came in that Monday, the two people who received the least votes and were hence leaving the show were these two:



and



Notice anything?

In case you're still missing it, here's what the top six looks like now, posing with host Natalie Bassingthwaighte:



Australia, you make me sick sometimes.

16 comments:

DaisyDeadhead said...

Just de-lurking from the USA to say... ohhh my goodness, Loredo is fine!

hexy said...

He IS, isn't he??

If you head to the website you can watch some of his dance solos. He almost never wears a shirt, and the drool factor added to his genuine brilliance as a dancer makes for some excellent viewing.

stephiepenguin said...

Ugh, thanks Australia. You always meet my expectations.

garbo in paint said...

I want to be surprised and yet... yeah, well.

Loreda... is so fine...

and damn it, I loved both Timomatic and Gianne... grrrr

hexy said...

After last week's results show, I turned to R and said "Bet you Timomatic goes next week."

His response was that he wasn't stupid enough to take that bet.

The REALLY upsetting bit is that I did a quick scan of the discussions about the episodes on the website. I found ONE person calling out the results as being racist, and no one replied to them. How is it not incredibly obvious that race played a part in these dancers leaving now??

garbo in paint said...

Also why did I call him Loreda and then reread it as Loredo?

garbo in paint said...

That'd be that white privilege thing again, I'd warrant.

hexy said...

I've just had someone on LJ respond to a comment I made on this topic on her thread about SYTYCD with "Oh, hon... not everything is a conspiracy, surely?"

*sigh*

Kitty said...

My LJ profile has the disclaimer, "I am equally amused and bewildered by the voting public of Australia, this includes Australian Idol."

I think I can now add the terms 'SYTYCD' and 'disgusted' to it. >:[

Gaina said...

Is it still really that bad in Oz? I know my friend spent a year there and I asked him how he'd sum it all up and he said 'Beautiful Country, but they are the most shocking racists I've ever dealt with'.

Had I not heard this from someone I know, I would have asked the same question 'is it just possible they were simply crap on that night and all happened to be black?'.

Is the wider media asking the same questions?

hexy said...

It doesn't seem to have been addressed by the wider media at all, at least not that I've seen. Also, all of those dancers got great feedback from the judges before being voted off.

Australian society, despite our claims of multiculturalism, is exceptionally white, especially once you move out of the major cities. There's also been a disturbing trend lately of young white Aussies embracing a backlash against immigrants. It's disgusting.

gooblyglob said...

I kinda stopped following it after Pania left :(

hexy said...

Pania was absolutely stunning.

Gaina said...

'hexy said...
It doesn't seem to have been addressed by the wider media at all, at least not that I've seen. Also, all of those dancers got great feedback from the judges before being voted off.

Australian society, despite our claims of multiculturalism, is exceptionally white, especially once you move out of the major cities. There's also been a disturbing trend lately of young white Aussies embracing a backlash against immigrants. It's disgusting'.
.

That sounds disturbingly like England right now. I just can't comprehend what level of stupidity you have to attain to judge people by the colour of their skin or the language they speak! That's just moronic to me.

Jet said...

Thanks for posting about this, hexy. That is ... yeah, predicatable. And disgusting. Thanks, Australia.

@Gaina ... Yes, still that bad. I think it has something to do with being an island. And a fair bit to do with the current crop of racist (they call themselves 'patriotic', of course) morons having been brought up under conservative, racist government.

My partner and I found a 'white power' sticker stuck to a wall in the city last week, pleading for white people to make a stand! before we are wiped out! oh no! We ripped it off, but that it was there in the first place? Yeah. Still that bad.

hexy said...

You found a WHAT??

Good lord. That's absolutely deplorable.